Substitution of rare ingredients?

Wayne111

  Dear Hands,

In the west it would be very difficult to use some of the rare ingredients in some formulas. By these I would refer to specifically rhinoceros horn and tiger bone. Are there any reasonable substitutes for these?

Wayne

hands

 

Dear Wayne,

So is difficult to use some of the materials in China!

Tiger bone and rhinoceros horn are prohibited from being in use in China, absolutely!

In my personal opinion, we don't have to use the tiger bones, which usually is good for fracture or for the very weak bone condition. But if possible, we could use some other animal bones instead, the most accessible one is dog bones. As a matter of fact even in old time, tiger bone was neither very popularly used, for it's very expensive. So dog bones were much more used instead. Or, if it's also very difficult for your people to get the dog bones, the other plant herbal materials are good enough. So, in brief, you could forget the tiger bone, or even the other animal bones.

 

But to talk about the rhinoceros horn is another story!

To tell the truth, there's nothing which is as good as it in treating the febrile diseases, such as SARS or H1N1 flu.

In traditioanl Chinese medicine, this product has been only used for saving human lives, most from febrile diseases!!!

It was never used as aphrodisiacs in traditional Chinese medicine, for it is not really good for that purpose and we have much more better materials.

 Now, we could only use bufflow horns instead, but the latter is much less effective. So some lives would have gone without the rhino horns. I would say nothing could be the substitute for rhino horn, no and never.

M.H.  

ximecmar

Dear Wayne:
I do not know the topic,
but I think, there are already homeopathically many combinations that can replace the use of these animal bones. Use these as we can break the law with its use ...
These homeopathic molecules give extraordinary results and if Wayne lives in the West can contact any German laboratory that produces them.

That's my contribution, I hope you find it useful.
Ximena

tutor

But to tell the truth, to treat febrile diseases, western medicine is not really as good as the Chinese herbs, including small number of animal or mineral products.
To reduce the fever, herbal medicaments are much more effective! If we have rhino horns, it would be much better, but we don't have it.

ximecmar

Thanks tutor,
for your input to this comment.


Xime

tutor

[quote][size=2][url=forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&pid=3007&ptid=1129][color=#999999] ximecmar 2016-12-20 05:41[/color][/url][/size]
Thanks tutor,
for your input to this comment.

[/quote]

ximecmar

Eternal gratitude for the knowledge TCM