My experience of diagnostic methods---Sophia

My experience of diagnostic methods
By Lady Sophia
Posted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 2:46 am

This post related to question in Forum of Course B “Anybody has good experience in tongue diagnosis? or other diagnostic methods?”, but I can’t to send post to this Forum, so I’m sending it to Acupuncture Forum. I’m not sure that my experience is good enough, however during many years I started each treatment from diagnostic. Unfortunately I didn’t study diagnostic methods in China, so undoubtedly I did a lot of mistakes and therefore opinion of specialists in TCM is valuable to me. For each patient I’m using folder with standard set of papers which I prepared: a questioning (for inquiring), pictures of face, tongue, eyes, ears, foots (to mark and to make a notes), pages for each treatment (to make notes about some new diagnostic findings, about the patient condition before and after treatment and about used acupoints and auxiliary methods). So after years I have a reference source for my work. First of all with each patient I’m going according to the next plan of diagnostic: A. Inquiring B. Inspection: 1. Observation of the face 2. Observation of the tongue 3. Observation of the eyes, including iridodiagnostics 4. Observation of the ears 5. Observation of the foot C. Palpation D. Auscultation and olfaction Only when all this diagnostic methods shown commensurable results, I’m started to think about concluding diagnosis. Two methods: observation of the face and auscultation and olfaction I’m carrying out at the time of inquiring. 1. I don’t think that I can add something new to face observation, but the next signs in my practice were sure for superfluity: redness of chin - Kidney red spots (or dilated vessels) on the left cheek - Liver red spots on the right cheek- Lung red spot (or eruption) on forehead (mainly between eyebrows) - Heart red and swollen lips – Spleen red nose – Stomach Signs of deficiency were less noticeable: small or flabby chin – Kidney brown spots on the left cheek (and other places) – Liver dry lips – Spleen wrinkles on forehead (mainly between eyebrows) – Heart protrusion of the head – deficiency of Qi (sign of the vitality?). For Lung most likely sign was common dryness and flabbiness of the skin. The Bladder problems were visible as swollen places (red or flabby) in zygomatic region. I observed them frequently for patients suffering from chronic prostatitis. There were other diagnostic signs too (such as different wrinkles), but signs described above were the most prevalent. 2. In tongue diagnosis in addition to observation of the color and form of the tongue proper and quality and color of the tongue coating for me was helpful to pay attention to features of tongue protrusion. Labored protrusion (deficiency, cold of the Heart), quaking tongue (deficiency of Yang), deviation to the right (exertion in the Lung) or to the left (exertion in the Liver) were very helpful signs. Red tip of the tongue was typical for Heart-heat (and mental pressure), while red lateral parts of the tongue were typical for Liver-heat (and shortness of temper). I have also observations of small signs on different parts on the tongue such as white packed areas (in cases of some tumors) or hemangiomas on lateral parts of the tongue (in cases hemangiomas in the liver). 3. In the part of observation of the eyes the next signs were most frequent. For superfluity: straw-colored sclera or/and surface irregularities of the sclera – Lung-heat red conjunctiva – Liver-heat yellow sclera – Gallbladder-heat red medial and lateral corners of the eye – Heart-heat Signs of deficiency: pale medial and lateral corners of the eye – Heart dimness of pupil - Kidney sunken eyes - deficiency of Qi (sign of the vitality?). Interesting that most of patients with straw-colored sclera or/and surface irregularities of the sclera appealed to oculist for medical aid, but they were considered by oculist as healthy persons. Sometimes small various signs (for example, red or brown spots) were observed on some parts on the eye or eyelids in cases of different diseases (such as red spot on lower eyelid in case of peptic ulcer of stomach). Among signs of the iris, sign in area of thyroid gland was very helpful. Nearly in each case of detection of lacuna in this area following blood test shown pathology of thyroid gland or inherited susceptibility. 4. Observation of the ears I did according to various signs on areas and acupuncture points of the ear. Red areas of course were connected with superfluity (area of the liver and gallbladder, area of the heart). Red ear lobule was typical for blood stagnation in the head. Furrow on the ear lobule was indicative of heart problems or/and diabetes. Appearance of wrinkles anterior to the ear was typical for sexual activity deterioration and for diminution of vitality. 5. Observation of the foot in my opinion is of greatest utility. During this diagnostic it was possible to determine physical and mental state of patient. For example, the common signs were: dry foot – diabetes, inactivity red foot – hypertonia, shortness of temper cold humid foot – deep emotion emptiness of the foot – tendency to cancer, diminution of vitality. For my opinion observation of the foot is the most significant for evaluation of the vitality. In many cases I observed strong foot constitution for old patients with excellent health. On the contrary emptiness of the foot for yang (good looking!) patients was bad prognostic sign. Division of the foot to 4 areas (from the heel to the toes) – earth, water, fire and air – and observation of this elements on their own place and in areas of other elements give a lot of addition information. I’m sorry, I can discuss this method too much time… If it is interesting to somebody I’ll give more detailed information. C. Palpation. 1. In this part I used only stomach palpation to make a comparison of upper and lower abdomen (temperature, flabbiness or tension) for evaluation of Kidney, Spleen (Bladdar, Stomach) state. I did not use this method for each patient because of touching to stomach is unpleasant for many of them. 2. I did not use feeling the pulse on account of difficulties in studying the pulse diagnosis without a good teacher. Instead of this I used Ryodoraku measurement, and it is very interesting for me to know opinion of specialists in TCM on this method. This method is based on checking of electro-conductivity of acupuncture points (Ryo – good, do – electro-conductive, raku - lineage system) and was described firstly by Nakatany (Nakatany, Y. A Guide for Application of Riodoraku Autonomous Nerve Regulatory Therapy. Tokio: Japanese Society of Ryodoraku Autonomic Nervous System,1972) and later by Koji Okazaki and others in Recent Advances in Acupunctere Research (Ed. F.F.Kao, J.J. Kao), 1979. According to the last publication I used for checking of electro-conductivity the next points: for the hand Meridians – Taiyuan LU9, Daling PC7, Shenmen HT7, Yangxi LI5, Yangchi SJ4, Yanggu SI5; for the foot Meridians – Taichong LR3, Taibai SP3, Taixi KI3, Qiuxu GB40, Chongyang ST42, Shugu BL65. As you can see most of them are Yuan-Primary Points. I’m only changed Shuiquan KI5 suggested in the article to Taixi KI3 because of some reasons: Shuiquan KI5 is Xi-Cleft Point and it is often painful, in cases of swollen instep it is easier to find Taixi KI3 precisely, and Taixi KI3 is a Yuan-Primary Point. My husband (he is a painter and designer) constructed for me very handy device, enabling quantitatively measure value of electro-conductivity (in microampere) of acupuncture points, rate and direction of changes of this value. After using this device during years I have statistics of comparison between this method, other diagnostic methods and state of patient. In each case of excess syndromes I observed high electro-conductivity in the point of corresponding meridian. A low values were typical for deficiency syndromes. When during measurement a value changes drastically, it was possible to draw a conclusion, that energy in certain meridian changes now (increases or decreases correspondingly). Of course pulse diagnosis gives more parameters for state characteristic of a meridian, but Ryodoraku measurement allows watching the patient state and describing it quantitatively. This measurement was useful to control process of treatment and to add some acupuncture points if value still too high or to lower. After successful course of treatments followed equilibrium condition characterized by nearly the same values of electro-conductivity for control points of each meridian. Sometimes at first treatment of old patients with chronic disease may be observed false equilibrium probably because of low resistibility (low vitality?). In this case was helpful first of all treat acupoints with common action, such as Hegu LI4, Neiguan PC6, Sanyinjiao SP6, Zusanli ST36 and others. That results in changing of false stability and showing up plausible reason of disease.

Dear Sophia,
Sorry it’s a bit too late to paste my opinions about your precious diagnostic experience herein.
However, I post it to the Forum of course B on the name of Lady Sophia.
Indeed you have done a great job in your practice of traditional Chinese medicine, and your experience of diagnosing diseases is of great value as I used to tell Serpent.
In fact, even in China, some TCM physicians would rely on the modern diagnostic techniques too much and don’t pay enough attention of the traditional ways and measurers, that’s BAD!!!
For sure as the time goes on, there have been a lot of changes in the TCM diagnostics, e.g. the simplification of the pulse taking. It is well known that in ancient time, (Han Dynasty, around 200 BC to 1800 AD), the pulse was taken in three regions of the body, not only that of the wrist. It was required to take the pulse for much long time for each patient in ancient time but nowadays it’s only a matter of couple of minutes. That’s because in clinic physicians have to work very hard to fulfill the demands of patients for there are too many patients here in the hospitals in China. So if you come one day here, you will know how many patients each doctor would have.
To observe a patient, at the moment, I (and majority of the TCM physicians, I think) would observe mainly their complexion and vitality on their face, so I can judge the deficiency or excess, and the vital conditions. To see the vitality, for sure the eyes are also important, which could also disclose the kidney condition apart from the complexion.
The complexion and the lips would help judge the function of the heart, I think the text has enough descriptions on this point.
Personally I did pay a great attention on the tongue, for sure to see both the body and coating.

...to be continued

(...continuing)
Besides I would also watch the ears a bit when I have a chance, but I would do it according to my own experience, not really the ear acupuncture theory.
Certainly the body is very helpful, so by the first impression you may have something basic.
What I’m going to stress is the pulse diagnosis!
Many people of TCM would complain that it’s TOO DIFFICULT to learn the pulse diagnosis!!! It is true the pulse diagnosis is of great difficulty, but not really as hard as they would think so!!!
Personally I do think it needs some talent but the right method is also helpful.
First of all, you’d better have a good reading about the descriptions on how various types of the pulses should feel like. For sure if you can read in Chinese, it would be much more helpful.
Secondly, you have to understand these descriptions! For instance, when it is said the string-taut pulse is straight and long, and feels like the string of a musical instrument like violin, you have to feel the pulse is not change along the course of the artery, and there is not curves in the course. And the surging pulse is compared to a tide, with a strong and powerful rising but a slow and subsiding retreating, so you should have the feeling of up and down.
(to be continued)

(...continuing)
The third is you should have someone (for sure a good teacher) who can tell you or even show what the types of the pulses are feel like.
The fourth and, I think, the most important is the talent and the practice. Only with good talent, you can have a right feeling and know how to distinguish the difference of the pulses; and with the practice, you may have the real feeling, so you can prove what you learned from the book or the teaching.
The fifth is when you take the pulse, you should also pay a lot of attention on the other diagnostic methods which are a bit easier to be understood, so you can check and prove your feeling of your pulse. For instance, you feel the pulse is thready, deep, and weak, and you find that the person’s tongue is pale and smaller, without much coating, the complexion is also a bit pale, the voice is a bit low, and the person looks weaker, so it’s sure you have a right feeling of the pulse.

to be continued

Thanks for Sophia sharing her experences.


Dear Tutor,

Do we need to pay attention on "Cun Guan Chi"? Becuase I feel some pulse different in 3 places, like left Cun are superficial, but Chi are week, can we think his Lung is exteriou and kidney is deficiency of Yang by that?

Thanks

Last edited by Zhen LI on Tue Mar 14, 2006 1:20 pm; edited 1 time in total

Yes, we must pay attention on the difference of the pulse taken respectively in the parts of Cun Guan Chi!
That's why we are doing the pulse diagnosis.
Every part would be more or less different from the other parts, so we could know the different conditions of the organs.
Personally I suggest you to review the connections between the organs and the places where you are taking the pulse, to make sure exactly the locations of the organs represented in the places or the pulse.

In my childhood, I got sick and it's prolonged and not get well despite several western medicine given (imagine more than 30 years ago). My father evetually took me to find a traditional Chinese doctor in my home town, he diagnosed my pulse,tongue,eye,and others and gave my father a prescription. Suprisingly, it's effective, my illness was cured in short time after taking some Chinese medicine. This in my first impression about TCM. Unfortunately, there was no TCM school in my country until the past two years and it requires five-year full class that is too late for me so I think Medboo course willl fullfil my desire to learn about TCM.

Just share my experience about the TCM diagnisis.
_________________
I love TCM

Yes, I think you have encountered a very experienced physician of traditional Chinese medicine! Lucky you!

That's why TCM is still very popular in China and is even spread to other countries of the world.

Many people would say herbal medicaments won't deal with the acute disorders, but in fact, herbs are also good for acute high fever, and if you could use it well, it works very quickly, within 30 minutes, a fever could be much lessened with the body temperature reduced for 2 degrees C.

To treat chronic fever, to tell the truth, western medicine sometimes couldn't do much for help, but traditional Chinese medicine could really be helpful, with herbs, or acupuncture, or Qigong.

Yes, Medboo tries the best to help the friends all over the world learn traditional Chinese medicine, we are working hard

I think that's also the advantage of the online teaching, so you might tailor your own timetable

Probably many friends won't really practice traditional Chinese medicine as a career later after the study with us, but I think the knowledge and the thinking mode would be quite beneficial to your daily life, even the way of coping with the interpersonal relations.